The Convention on the Future of Europe, March 2002

Author (Person)
Publisher
Series Title
Series Details 1.3.02
Publication Date 01/03/2002
Content Type , ,

A new chapter in the history of Europe was opened on 28 February 2002 just as another important chapter in Europe's history closed. While European citizens across the eurozone spent their last national coins and banknotes before they ceased to be legal tender, the attention of Europe's media and key figures was focussed on the launch of the Convention on the Future of Europe. One of the key aims of the Convention is to close the growing gap between the European Union and its citizens as well as improving the efficiency of the policy making process and the institutions so that the organisation can cope with future enlargement which is set to begin in 2004.

The Convention is widely seen as a milestone for the EU and a determining event if the organisation is to have a successful future. Speaking at the launch of the Convention, its President, Valéry Giscard d'Estaing recognised its importance, saying,

'On one side, the yawning abyss of failure. On the other strait, is the gate to success.
If we fail, we will add to the current confusion in the European project. What has been created over fifty years will reach its limit, and be threatened with dislocation'
Introductory speech to the Convention on the Future of Europe

Background

Joschka Fischer, the German Foreign Minister, is often seen to have ignited the debate on the future of the European Union in a speech he made in May 2000 entitled 'From Confederacy to Federation - Thoughts on the finality of European integration'. This outlined his views of 'the possible strategic prospects for European integration far beyond the coming decade and the intergovernmental conference'.

Fischer's speech sparked a series of key speeches by important European figures such as Romani Prodi, President of the European Commission; Jacques Chirac, the President of France; and Tony Blair, the UK Prime Minister, on the future development of the European Union.

[See European Sources Online's previous In Focus: The European debate: Germany, France and the United Kingdom, July 2000]

The debate was further fuelled by the 'IGC 2000' [See European Sources Online's In Focus: Launch of the Intergovernmental Conference 2000, February 2000] which was ongoing at the time and the Nice European Council which led to a 'Declaration on the Future of the European Union' [See European Sources Online's In Focus: European Council, Nice, 7-11 December 2000 / Treaty of Nice]. The Declaration annexed to the Treaty of Nice called for two phases aimed at deepening and widening the debate on the future of the European Union. The first phase would encourage a wide-ranging exchange of views from multiple and national sources while the second phase would be a structured reflection of the future of the Union.

The debate on the future of Europe was officially opened at the European School in Brussels on 7 March 2001. The second phase of structural reflection, as scheduled in the Nice timetable, was defined at the Laeken European Council held on 15 December 2001 when the Laeken Declaration on the Future of the European Union was adopted[See European Sources Online's In Focus: European Council, Laeken, 14-15 December 2001].

The Laeken European Council decided that the best way to conduct this 'structural reflection' was by establishing a Convention to debate the future of the European Union for a year. The Convention would begin in March 2002, in preparation for the next intergovernmental conference in 2004. Its starting point would be some 56 questions agreed upon at Laeken. The European Council also agreed at this point upon the mandate and the institutional structure of the Convention as well as outlining a number of indications on how it should operate in terms of deliberation, drafting and decision-making.

Convention on the Future of Europe

  • Composition

All the Member States of the European Union as well as the thirteen candidate countries will be represented on the Convention. The 105 members come from a range of backgrounds: all national parliaments in the Member States and candidate countries have two representatives with a further 16 representatives from the European Parliament. There is one representative form each of the 28 governments and the European Commission has two representatives. There are also representatives from non-governmental organisations and academia. A full list of the Convention members is available on the Convention's website.

Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, the former French President, was chosen by leaders at the European Council in Laeken in December to chair the Convention. His appointment was questioned in certain sectors, largely because of his age. Many felt that at 76 and with a 45 year political career behind him, he was not the right person to lead a debate about the EU's future and to reconnect it with its citizens, especially the younger generations. Giscard d'Estaing himself also stirred more controversy about his appointment by demanding huge wages and benefits. Demands he later withdrew.

Two vice chairmen - former prime ministers, Jean-Luc Dehaene of Belgium and Giuliano Amato of Italy - will help Giscard d'Estaing, with Dehaene assigned the special task of organising a 'forum' to elicit citizens' views. Sir John Kerr, the UK's ambassador to the EU between 1990 and 1995, will act as the Convention's Secretary General.

Aside from the criticism surrounding Giscard d'Estaing's appointment, the composition of the Convention has also fuelled controversy because of the lack of female members. The European Women's Lobby has begun a campaign to increase the number of women involved in EU decision making and issued a press release saying,

EWL deplores the imbalance in the representation of women in the Presidium where out of a total of 12 members, there are only 2 women, Ana de Palacio from Spain and Gisela Stuart from the United Kingdom, and in the Convention which at this time includes 16 women out of a total of the 87 members already nominated.
The Convention on the Future of Europe has the very important task of preparing the ground for the European Union of tomorrow and it does seem to us unthinkable that the Presidium and the Convention will begin their work without addressing this fundamental deficit in the representation of women's rights and interests
European Women's Lobby Press Release

The European Youth Forum has also criticised the absence of anyone under the age of thirty five on the convention, saying in a press release,

'The Convention on the Future of Europe will be facing the specific challenge of bringing Europe closer to its young citizens, as set out in the Laeken Declaration. However, given that the average age of the sixty-six full members of the Convention is 54 and that the youngest is 37, they may, despite their experience, be out of touch with the issues that matter to younger Europeans.
European Youth Forum

Clearly, certain civil society organisations feel that the composition of the Convention may affect its ability to fulfill its task

  • Mandate

The actual task of the 105 members is in fact extremely broad. As Michel Barnier, European Commissioner for regional policy and institutional reform and one of the European Commission's representatives, said the real question is,

'What kind of Europe do we want? What do we want to achieve together and, above all, what can we achieve together?

Clearly the overall aim is to make the European Union workable with as many as twenty eight members while also taking it closer to European citizens. With these goals in mind the Laeken European Council identified four key issues which need to be discussed at the Convention:

  • the division of responsibilities between the EU and the Member States
  • simplification of the European treaties
  • the status of the European Charter of Fundamental Rights
  • the role of national parliaments within the European Union.

In addition, the Convention is also likely to address the role of the European Union in global affairs and how foreign policy should best be handled in a new multipolar world.

Throughout the course of the Convention there is likely to be much opposition between the pro and anti-federalists with the possibility of a constitution, in some form, on the cards. However, Giscard d'Estaing is said to be luke warm towards federalism and Giuliano Amato, while being prepared to consider an EU governing constitution has emphasised that this would only be possible if it were approved in an EU wide referendum.

  • Inaugural Session

All of the ambitious tasks of the Convention were highlighted at its inaugural session which took place on 28 February 2002 in Brussels. The session opened with an address by the President of the European Council, José M.Aznar, who argued that a crisis in the integration process did not exist but that the current world situation made it 'imperative for the Union to quicken the pace of its advance'. He cited the ideas of a European philosopher, the Spaniard Ortega y Gasset as a reason building a strong EU saying,

'Ortega y Gasset called for the unity of the European states in order to counteract nationalism and the danger of decline in this region of the world called "Europe". In this connection, the European Union at this time must sense the urgency of redefining its role in a world deeply transformed at the passing of one century to another'.

Aznar also emphasised the need to close the gap between the Union and its citizens, declaring that the major objective of the work of the Convention must be,

'to project a sustainable and effective Europe: a Europe in which all its citizens may enjoy, on an equal basis, the benefits of the internal market, the single currency and the European social model. If Europe has a future... it must be something in which Europeans truly believe, and which they support and evaluate positively.

The importance of reconnecting the Union with its citizens was also highlighted by Pat Cox, President of the European Parliament, who made a speech directly after Aznar. Cox highlighted the particular significance which the European Parliament attaches to dialogue with citizens and civil society and urged the Convention to 'be a talking but also a listening Convention' saying,

'Our earnest wish is that this Convention should pave the way for a permanent dialogue with our peoples, the social partners, civil society, states and regions. The ultimate test of the Convention being launched here today will be its ability to harness a collective wisdom and will; to forge a balanced and practical reform of what we do in common as Europeans and how we do it; and to do so in terms that will commend themselves decisively to the next Intergovernmental Conference on Treaty reform.

Representing the other key EU institution, the European Commission, Romano Prodi highlighted the unique nature of the European Unionsaying,

The Union is not, nor should it become a new League of Nations, reduced to impotence by selfishness and the right of veto. The European Union offers a harmonious model of supranational democracy. It is the only real attempt to globalise democratically, in such a manner as to provide rights and growth. For this reason it can play a very special role in the world today and tomorrow. European Commission: SPEECH/02/88

Following this introduction, it was time for the Convention's Chairman to speak. Giscard d'Estaing spoke of the development of European integration since the 1950s and urged the Convention to continue with this progress. He gave details of the members of the Convention as well as outlining the main aims. These include addressing two particular groups of European citizens: the younger generation and the citizens in the candidate countries. The chairman also suggested that the Convention should carry out an extensive survey to find out what Europeans want from the EU in fifty years time. Following the listening phase, the Convention would then have to examine 'the various prescriptions for Europe's Future

which others have put forward' and he specifically mentioned the following formulae:

  • the organisation of the European institutions resulting from the Treaty of Nice;
  • the plan for a Europe organised along federal lines, as put forward by high-level German decision-makers in particular;
  • the document prepared by the European Commission on modernising the Community method;
  • the solutions submitted under the banner of a "federation of nation states", whether or not they involve the creation of a second chamber.
  • The Future of the Convention

With the Convention on the Future of Europe officially launched, the presidium will now meet at least twice a month to carry out its work with a plenary session of the Convention to be held once a month in public. The first plenary session is scheduled for 21 and 22 March 2002. [For details of other meeting consult the Convention's timetable]. The first draft of a report should be published by the Convention in Summer 2002 and its final report in June 2003 with proposals for a new treaty to follow.

As for the success of the Convention on the Future of Europe, it certainly promises much in theory. For the first time in its history the European Union is actually sitting down and conducting a thorough appraisal of itself, its work and its institutions as highlighted by Giscard d'Estaing who said,

[the] 'Convention represents the first occasion since the Messina Conference in 1955 for European leaders to set aside the resources and time to examine in detail the future of the European Union'.

However, the question remains as to what the Convention can achieve, especially in redressing the democratic deficit. In his introductory speech at the inaugural session of the Convetion, Giscard d'Estaing spoke of the importance of the single currency, saying,

In changing their currency, showing a remarkable capacity to adapt and a sort of popular joy,302 million Europeans have just cast off the reproach of euro-sclerosis and shown that they are able to approve what is proposed to them when they judge it to be simple and useful.

But can the Convention on the Future of Europe achieve the same in overcoming the euro-sclerosis throughout the EU? It is quite possible that the 28 February 2002 will be more significant in terms of making Europeans feel more involved in the European Union because everyone in the eurozone is now using the same currency rather than because the Convention on the Future of Europe got underway.

Further information within European Sources Online:

European Sources Online: In Focus
12.11.99: Preparations for IGC 2000: Report of the Group of Wise Men on the institutional implications of enlargement and Commission follow-up, November 1999
20.02.00: Launch of the Intergovernmental Conference 2000, February 2000
01.07.00: The European debate: Germany, France and the United Kingdom, July 2000
07.10.00: The future development of the European Union: The debate continues with speeches by Romano Prodi, Strasbourg, 3 October 2000 and Tony Blair, Warsaw, 6 October 2000
11.12.00: European Council, Nice, 7-11 December 2000 / Treaty of Nice
03.03.01: Treaty of Nice signed 26 February 2001. What next for the European Union?, February 2001
15.12.01: European Council, Laeken, 14-15 December 2001
 
European Sources Online: European Voice
18.10.01: Youth groups called for 'united' Union
18.10.01: Call for common EU goal to win public appeal
20.12.01: The future of the European Union: The Laeken Declaration
24.01.02: Women demand a role in elite
14.02.02: Convention delay looms amid wrangles
 
European Sources Online: Financial Times
21.01.02: UK wants EU 'super council'
23.01.02: Tory eurosceptic seeks place at convention on future of EU
Special report: The Future of the EU [FT.com]
25.02.02: The elder's statesman's brief [FT.com]
25.02.02: Fini gains respectability in corridors of power [FT.com]
25.02.02: Frequently asked questions [FT.com]
26.02.02: Opening time [FT.com]
26.02.02: Questions and answers on Europe's future [FT.com]
26.02.02: EU accused of sidelining smaller members [FT.com]
27.02.02: Jean-Luc Dehaene, convention vice-chairman [FT.com]
27.02.02: Approaching a constitution for Europe [FT.com]
28.02.02: A citizens' Europe: The creation of constitutional principles will check the growth of the Brussels bureaucracy, says Larry Siedent [FT.com]
28.02.02: We the people [FT.com]
28.02.02: Europe's dates with destiny [FT.com]
28.02.02: Giscard dreams of a stronger, bigger EU [FT.com]
01.03.02: Agenda likely to set pace for closer integration [FT.com]
01.03.02: A dream that needs democracy [FT.com]

Further information can be seen in these external links:

(long-term access cannot be guaranteed)

EU Institutions

European Commission

DG Press and Communication

Documents
  28.02.02: Convention websites [DOC/02/6]
  28.02.02: Inaugural session of the Convention [DOC/02/5]
Speeches
  11.12.01: The state of The Union: '2002, a decisive step towards a greater Europe' [Romano Prodi: SPEECH/01/621]
  13.12.01: Building the new Europe together [Romano Prodi: SPEECH/01/630]
  17.12.01: Laeken: Signpost to the Future [Romano Prodi: SPEECH/01/636]
  22.02.02: Towards a more resolute and influential European Union [Michel Barnier: SPEECH/02/80]
  27.02.02: Annual policy for 2003 and the Convention [Romano Prodi: SPEECH/02/86]
  28.02.02: Opening session of the Convention on the Future of Europe [Romano Prodi: SPEECH/02/88]
Memos
  28.02.02: The Convention and the debate on the future of the European Union on the Internet [MEMO/02/41]

European Parliament
The Future of Europe

Council of the European Union
14.12.01: Laeken Presidency Conclusions
15.12.01: Laeken Declaration - The Future of the European Union
Convention on the Future of Europe
Homepage
  Composition
  Presidium
  Documents
  Forum
Futurum
Homepage

National Organisations

United Kingdom: Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Speeches
    29.01.02: The future of Europe: Time for a new vision
Forum: The Future of Europe [Forum now closed, archived forum available]
 
United Kingdom: House of Commons
01.05.01: The Treaty of Nice and the Future of Europe debate [Research Paper 01/49]

Miscellaneous Organisations

Centre for European Policy Studies
Homepage
Policy briefs
  The Convention on the Future of the EU [CEPS Policy Brief No.11 - February 2002]
  The assignment of tasks in an evolving European Union [CEPS Policy Brief No.10 - January 2002]

The European Policy Centre
Homepage
The Europe we need
Challenge Europe
  12.01.02: The Convention on the Future of Europe, March 2002
Breakfast Notes
  01.02.01: Preparing for a Constitution for the European Union
  25.09.01: Addressing Europe's democratic deficit
  28.11.01: The making of a democratic European constitution
  04.10.01: The future of the Union
Dialogues
  17.10.01: From Ghent to Laeken and beyond
  12.12.01: Laeken Declaration: The way forward?
Communications
  26.02.02: The future functioning of the European Union
  16.12.01: The Laeken Summit: A milestone for Europe

European Youth Forum
Homepage
Press Release
  28.02.02: Convention on the Future of Europe: Should we be bracing ourselves for another old-style EU?

European Women's Lobby
Homepage
Press Release
  27.02.02: Convention on the Future of Europe: Where are the women?

Berlin University: European Student Conference
Homepage: The Making of Europe - Guidelines of European Policy in the 21st Century
Memorandum

News Organisations

BBC News Online
13.12.01: Big changes ahead for EU
13.12.01: Europe's blueprints for reform
14.12.01: Ambition and dissent in Laeken
15.12.01: Profile: Giscard d'Estaing
15.12.01: Blair 'confident' over EU future
15.12.01: EU steels itself to 'deliver results'
15.12.01: EU prepares major reform
17.12.01: Viewpoint: Laeken's lows
17.12.01: EU must streamline - Blair
17.12.01: Analysis: The future of Europe debate
18.12.01: Belgium's unfulfilled presidential plans
09.01.02: Profile: Italy's post-fascist hopeful
21.01.02: French veteran demands EU perks
24.01.02: Post-fascist Fini takes EU job
24.01.02: Hain appointed to key EU convention
25.01.02: Giscard d'Estaing refused EU salary
25.01.02: Italy heads for new EU storm
28.01.02: Berlusconi wins EU battle
21.02.02: Straw supports an EU 'constitution'
21.02.02: Britain gets real in the Europe debate
26.02.02: Q&A: Convention on the Future of Europe
28.02.02: EU launches democratic drive
28.02.02: Hain denies superstate move
28.02.02: Analysis: EU gets down to business
28.02.02: European Press Review:

Further and subsequent information on the subject of this In Focus can be found by an 'Advanced Search' in European Sources Online by inserting 'Convention on the Future of Europe' or 'Future of the Union' in the keyword field.

Helen Bower
Compiled: 1 March 2002

Overview of the Convention on the Future of Europe - its origins, its members and its objectives - following its inaugural session on 28 February 2002.

Subject Categories