Tax Legislation within the Scope of EU-State Aid Law: An Overview of Critical Issues Arising from the German ‘Reorganization Clause’

Author (Person)
Series Title
Series Details Vol.40, No.6/7, June / July 2012, p414-420
Publication Date June 2012
ISSN 0165-2826
Content Type

Pasquale Pistone stressed very recently in this journal `the growing importance of the prohibition of state aids in tax matters´ (Intertax 2012, p. 84). This is a fair point. The following article illustrates and expands upon this by focusing on critical issues arising from the German 'reorganization clause' by way of example. For a business, it is important to understand when it might be in a position to bring an action before the General Court. Furthermore, the question arises what makes a tax clause, such as the German reorganization clause, selective in nature. At a glance, a tax rule seems to have a general character which is not likely to constitute a form of aid.

Moreover, given that as things stand there remains considerable uncertainty surrounding the question when a tax measure constitutes unlawful State Aid, where a Commission decision breaks new ground. In that respect, the question arises whether a decision of the Commission which finds a tax rule to be State Aid may have retroactive effect or whether this retroactive effect would violate the protection of the legitimate expectations of the taxpayers.

Source Link Link to Main Source http://www.kluwerlawonline.com/index.php?area=Journals
Subject Categories ,
Countries / Regions