Quartet aims to guide Middle East on the road to peace, May 2003

Author (Person)
Publisher
Series Title
Series Details 3.5.03
Publication Date 06/05/2003
Content Type , ,

After months of intense diplomatic efforts, the Quartet of mediators in the Middle East Peace Process - representatives from the European Union, the United Nations, Russia and the United States of America - presented their long awaited "roadmap" to peace in the Middle East on 30 April 2002.

Although the US government has dominated the presentation of the roadmap, from the European perspective it is a signal of the EU's commitment to the region and a much needed example of the EU's ability to play a key role in international affairs after the disarray over Iraq.

Commenting on the roadmap, the EU's High Representative, Javier Solana, said:

"The European Union is part of the Quartet, and as such will follow the development of the Roadmap. We are all going to work so that it gets implemented rapidly. Implementation is my major concern. Because we have had already so many documents that have never been implemented. I would like very much that this one - that has the full support of the whole international community: President Bush, the European Union, the Russian Federation and the Secretary General of the UN, Kofi Annan - is implemented rapidly. We have an opportunity to bring about a reality that is the dream of everybody, which is two states that can live together in a neighbourhood in which both states are fully recognised and live in peace".
Remarks by EU HR Javier Solana, Brussels, 1 May 2003

Background

Over the course of spring 2002 the world witnessed the situation in the Middle East deteriorate and the escalation of violence in the region continues to date. The suffering of hundred of Arabs and Israelis in Jerusalem and the West Bank has highlighted the urgent need for a solution to the long-standing problem in the Middle East and encouraged the key actors on the international stage to get involved in the quest for peace.

It is in this context that the European Union has sought to play a role in the peace brokering process. Not only is it keen to see peace and stability brought to this area not far from its own borders but the situation also offers the European Union the opportunity to carve itself a role as a more powerful player on the global stage.

In recent years, the European Union has demonstrated its commitment to the region through financial support, providing an average of €179 million a year over the past six years in direct support of the Palestinian Authority, refugees and regional Peace Process projects, and through political and diplomatic efforts. Since the European Union's basic position on the Middle East Peace Process (MEPP) was first expressed in the Venice Declaration on the Middle East at the June 1980 European Council it has been repeatedly reaffirmed at subsequent European Councils as well as by General Affairs Councils of Foreign Ministers.

A detailed commentary covering the background to the Middle East conflict and the EU's role in the MEPP can be found in European Sources Online's previous In Focus: The European Union and the Middle East Peace Process, April 2002. Additional information can also be found on the European Commission's website concerning the Middle East Peace Process.

The EU and the Middle East Quartet

Although the EU has undoubtedly played a political and economic role in the peace process over the last two decades, it has not been at the forefront of negotiations, that position has been occupied by the United States. However, since the beginning of 2002 it has sought a more active role: in February 2002, on the initiative of the French government, the EU sought to launch a new peace plan suggesting that the deadlock could be broken by Yassir Arafat's Palestinian Authority seeking a fresh mandate through elections.

In reality, the escalation of violence in March 2002 and the further deterioration in negotiations hampered the EU's efforts but these did succeed in stimulating greater US involvement in the Middle East Peace Process. On 5 April 2002, President Bush issued a keynote statement in which he announced that the US Secretary of State, Colin Powell, would visit the Middle East with the aim of negotiating a ceasefire.

Responding to Bush's statement President of the European Commission, Romano Prodi, said,

"We support US Secretary of State Powell's efforts to halt the violence and bring sanity back to the region".

This support was reinforced in a meeting on 11 April 2002 in Madrid when representatives from the UN, Russia, the US and Europe met to discuss the Middle East conflict. The Madrid Conference was effectively the beginning of what has become known as the "Middle East Quartet" as the four groups agreed to present the Palestinian Authority and Israel with a united front. In a declaration issued by the group they called for an immediate ceasefire, for Israel to withdraw immediately from the Palestinian self-rule areas, and for Mr Arafat to unequivocally denounce suicide bombers.

Two months later after Palestinian terrorist attacks continued unabated, the US demonstrated a significant shift in policy when President Bush made a speech on 24 June 2002 explicitly calling for "a new and different" Palestinian leadership. While many commentators felt the US' new approach to the Middle East would influence the position of the Quartet, the general conclusion was that the results of the second meeting of the Middle East Quartet in New York on 16 July 2002 were more in parallel with the position reached in Madrid than that outlined in President Bush's speech of 24 June 2002. In New York, representatives welcomed Palestinian efforts at economic and political reform and reasserted their commitment to achieve a peaceful solution to the crisis.

The first clear signal that the Quartet intended to produce a detailed action plan for peace came at the third meeting of the group in New York on 17 December 2002 at which they announced:

"The Quartet is working closely with the parties and consulting key regional actors on a concrete, three-phase implementation roadmap that could achieve a final settlement within three years. Comprehensive security performance is essential. The plan will not succeed unless it addresses political, economic, humanitarian, and institutional dimensions and should spell out reciprocal steps to be taken by the parties in each of its phases".

The foundations of the roadmap may well have originated in Europe as the European Union had drafted a similar style peace plan in Summer 2002 aimed at "filling the gaps" left by President Bush's speech. Indeed much of the early momentum behind the Middle East Road Map appears to have been EU driven: it was Javier Solana and Chris Patten who pushed for the roadmap to be published by the end of 2002, arguing that the process needed to be given further momentum if the 2005 deadline for the creation of a Palestine state was to be met. Ultimately, Washington's view that the blueprint was not complete won out and its publication was delayed until 2003 but Mr. Solana was prepared to publicly bemoan the lack of a committed American partner in the process.

The Quartet's Road Map to Peace in the Middle East

So, just over a year after the Quartet first met in Madrid on 11 April 2003, the long awaited Performance-Based Roadmap to a Permanent Two-State Solution to the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict was released on 30 April 2003.

In the event, its presentation was so dominated by the US, one might have been excused for failing to realise that the document was actually a joint effort of the United Nations, the European Union and Russia in addition to the United States. In fact, the publication of the roadmap so soon after the war in Iraq appeared to be coming to an end, may largely be attributed to the UK Prime Minister Tony Blair who levied pressure on President Bush to make a clear commitment to achieving peace in the region following the coalition forces attack on Iraq. The eventual publication of the document was also made possible after a new Palestinian administration took office on 29 April 2003.

The Roadmap sets out three phases on the route to a final and comprehensive settlement of the Israel-Palestinian conflict by 2005:

Phase 1 [Present to May 2003] End of terrorism
  Normalisation of Palestinian life
  Palestinian political reform
  Israeli withdrawal and end of settlement activity
  Drafting of constitution for Palestinian statehood
  Free and open Palestinian elections
     
Phase 2 [June-December 2003] Creation of an independent Palestinian state
  International conference and international monitoring of compliance with roadmap
     
Phase 3 [2004-2005] Second international conference
  Permanent status agreement and end of conflict
  Agreement on final borders, Jerusalem, refugees and settlements
  Arab states to agree to peace deals with Israel

All those involved in the Middle East Peace Process are aware that the commitment now required by both Palestinian and Israeli leaders for the roadmap to succeed is enormous but similarly everyone is aware that it offers one of the most significant opportunities for lasting peace in the region.

The Palestinian Administration enthusiastically welcomed the "roadmap" and the new Palestinian Foreign Minister, Nabil Shaath, called for immediate implementation of the plan, according to the Associated Press news agency. However, the Israeli government reacted cautiously to the proposal, saying they would take time to consider its details before making any further comment.

Much will depend on the ability of the new Palestinian Prime Minister, Mahmoud Abbas, and his cabinet to control attacks by Palestinian militants on Israelis. Mr. Abbas is well known for his criticism of these militant attacks but his ability to prevent them is unproven. The day before the roadmap was published three people were killed in a suicide bomb attack on a café in Tel Aviv and Hamas, the group purported to be responsible for these attacks, has openly rejected the "roadmap" outright.

Yet despite these challenges, leaders from the European Union have expressed their hopes for future peace in the region and reaffirmed their commitment to the process. President of the European Commission, Romano Prodi, said:

"I welcome the presentation of the Quartet Road Map to the parties as a means to re-launch the Peace Process, and an important stabilising factor for the entire region. The Road Map offers the best chance of achieving the vision of a two-state solution set out by President Bush last summer."

His fellow European Commissioner, Chris Patten, responsible for the EU's external relations added:

"It is in the interest of both parties to start making rapid progress to implement the provisions of the Road Map with the support of the international community. Too much blood has been shed: it is imperative to re-energise the quest for peace without further delay. The Commission looks forward to working with the Quartet partners in support of the implementation of the Road Map."

In a strong demonstration of support for the roadmap, the EU announced on the same day as its publication new forms of assistance to support the reform process in the Palestinian Authority, bringing the level of assistance foreseen for the Palestinian Territories in 2003 to €245million. The additional aid will be provided through a new Reform Support Instrument targeted on the payment of arrears to small enterprises and social services and a new form of technical assistance to facilitate implementation of reforms of public finance.

The joint announcement of both the Quartet's roadmap and the new financial support measures reflect the EU's commitment to the Middle East region. After the disarray over Iraq, the EU's role in the Quartet's successful implementation of the "roadmap" could do much to strengthen the EU's Common Foreign and Security Policy whilst going some way to healing the transatlantic rift.

Since early 2002, the European Union has proved its ability to levy a certain amount of pressure on the US to intervene in the Middle East and to play its role, albeit in the superpower's shadows. However, with several Arab states cautious about US intentions in the region after the war against Iraq there could yet be an opportunity for the EU to take on a more significant role and more importantly help to bring an end to more than half a century of conflict.

Further information within European Sources Online:

European Sources Online: In Focus
The European Union and the Middle East Peace Process, April 2002
 
European Sources Online: European Voice
14.03.02: EU needs "resolute" Middle East stance
21.03.02: Israel set to escape claims over damage to EU sites
04.04.02: Palestinians seek EU arms ban on Israel
18.04.02: Plea for more help in Middle East
25.04.02: Solana in Arafat visit
23.05.02: EU still lacks credibility in Middle East - envoy
18.07.02: Israel says EU should stay out of Middle East peace process
12.09.02: Israel cool on Danish Middle East plans
07.11.02: EU sticks with Middle East roadmap amid uncertainty
27.02.03: EU to tell US to stay focussed on Middle East
 
European Sources Online: Financial Times
11.02.02: EU aims to launch radical Mid East peace plan
13.02.02: Washington turns deaf ear to Europe's divided voices
01.04.02: Europe frustrated by 'inconsistent' Washington Middle East policy
04.04.02: EU attacks "inadequate" action by US
06.04.02: Brussels welcomes US intervention
11.04.02: EU throws its weight behind Powell's mission to the region
15.04.02: Israelis warn EU not to impose sanctions
16.04.02: Ministers support Powell's ceasefire efforts
14.05.02: EU puts off decision on countries for Palestinian exiles
26.06.02: EU leaders rule lack of peace process
27.06.02: The old argument
27.06.02: Europeans to seek Bush change of heart
29.06.02: Divided Europe won't sway Washington
29.06.02: EU to put forward MidEast peace process plan
10.07.02: Berlin presents new MidEast peace plan
16.09.02: No voice in Washington
21.03.03: Europe needs its own plan for the MidEast

Further information can be seen in these external links:
(long-term access cannot be guaranteed)

EU Institutions

European Commission DG Press and Communication
Press Releases:
  30.04.03: EU to support reform of Palestinian Authority with new forms of aid [IP/03/607]
  30.04.03: President Romano Prodi and Commissioner Chris Patten welcome the approval by the Palestinian Legislature of the new Palestinian Authority Cabinet [IP/03/610]
  30.04.03: European Commission welcomes Quartet's presentation of the Middle East Road Map [IP/03/612]
 
European Commission: DG External Relations
Homepage
The EU and the Middle East Peace Process
  Documents and Links on the Middle East Peace Process
  The EU's relations with Israel
 
Council of the European Union
Homepage
  Press Releases
  23.04.03: EUHR Javier SOLANA welcomes the agreement upon the composition of the Palestinian Authority's Cabinet
  29.04.03: HR Javier Solana welcomes the approval of the Palestinian Authority's Prime Minister and his Cabinet - Brussels, 29 April 2003
  30.04.03: Joint Statement by Middle East Quartet on Road Map and full text
  01.05.03: Remarks by EU HR Javier SOLANA on the occasion of meetings with the Israeli and Palestinian representatives in Brussels, following the presentation of the "Road Map", 1 May 2003
 
International Organisations
 
United Nations
Question of Palestine
 
United Nations: Permanent Observer Mission of Palestine to the United Nations
Homepage
 
United Nations: Permanent Mission of Israel to the United Nations
Homepage
 
National Organisations
 
Israel: Israeli Government
Homepage
 
Israel: Prime Minister's Office
Homepage
 
Israel: Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Homepage
A Handbook to the Peace Process
 
Palestine: Palestinian National Authority
Homepage
 
Palestine: Palestinian Liberation Organisation
Negotiation Affairs Department
 
United States: Department of State
Middle East Peace Process
  Middle East Quartet Statements
 
United States Report on the Middle East
Homepage
 
United Kingdom: Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Homepage
Middle East Peace Process
  Frequent Questions and Answers
  Historical background
 
France: Ministère des Affaires étrangères (Ministry of Foreign Affairs)
Homepage
Situation au Proche-Orient
 
Germany: Auswärtiges Amt (Foreign Office)
Homepage
Federal Minister Fischer to meet Nabil Shaath
 
Miscellaneous Organisations
 
The Washington Institute for Near East Policy
Homepage
Subtle backtracking: Assessing the Quartet's New York statement [July 2002]
The Quartet Roadmap, Take Two: Still at Odds with Bush's June 24 Speech [December 2002]
Through street or cul de sac? Assessing the latest Quartet Roadmap [December 2002]
Inside a flawed "Roadmap": Truth or consequences for the peace process [February 2003]
 
MidEast web
Homepage
  Middle East Historical and Peace Process Documents
  Timeline of the Palestinian Israeli History and the Israel-Palestine Conflict
 
Bertelsmann Foundation
Homepage
Project Overview: Europe and the Middle East
  Strategy Paper - Kronberg III/1997
  Strategy Paper - Kronberg IV/1998
  Strategy Paper - Kronberg V/1999
  Strategy Paper - Kronberg VI/2000
  Strategy Paper - Kronberg VII/2002

News Organisations

BBC News Online
07.02.02: Europe's growing MidEast role
09.02.02: EU split on Middle East
13.02.02: Analysis: EU split on Middle East
27.02.02: Mid-East diplomacy stepped up
04.04.02: EU team meets Israeli leaders
04.04.02: EU abandons peace mission
15.04.02: Q&A: Middle East peace conference
15.04.02: EU ministers reject Israel sanctions
16.07.02: Mid-East Quartet's muted tone
17.07.02: Analysis: Discord among Mid-East Quartet
17.09.02: Attempts to relaunch Mid-East peace
18.10.02: US plans Mid-East "roadmap"
21.12.02: Mid-East peace plan "not ready"
18.02.03: Q&A: Middle East peace conflict
24.04.03: Mid-East's "political theatre"
30.04.03: Rocky road to mid-East peace
30.04.03: New Mid-East peace plan launched
02.05.03: Roadmap 'breathtakingly ambitious'
03.05.03: Timeline - Recent Middle East Peace Process

Further and subsequent information on the subject of this In Focus can be found by an 'Advanced Search' in European Sources Online by inserting 'Middle East' in the keyword field.

Helen Bower

Compiled: 3 May 2003

On 30 April 2003, the Middle East 'Quartet' made up of representatives from the EU, Russia, the UN and the United States of America presented their long awaited 'roadmap' to peace in the region.

Countries / Regions