Non-compliance with EU Directives in the Member States: opposition through the backdoor?

Abstract:

To what extent are European rules complied with, and what are the reasons for non-compliance with EU law? According to an intergovernmentalist perspective, implementation problems should occur when Member States failed to assert their interests in the European decision-making process. Focusing on 26 infringement procedures from the area of labour law, the authors show that such 'opposition through the backdoor' does occur occasionally. However, the study demonstrates that opposition at the end of the EU policy process may also arise without prior opposition at the beginning. Additionally, the findings indicate that non-compliance is often unrelated to opposition, and due to administrative shortcomings, interpretation problems, and issue linkage. This study is based on unique in-depth data stemming from a ground-level analysis of the implementation of six EU Directives in all 15 Member States.