Financial Engineering Instruments and their Assessment Under EU State Aid Rules

Financial engineering instruments such as guarantees, loans and equity are increasingly used in public funding of enterprises. These instruments have three attractive features: they are repayable, they ‘leverage’ private involvement, and they have a multiplier effect because they generate new income. At the same time, however, they are technically complex and they are subject to state aid rules. Their assessment under EU state aid rules creates two additional problems.

First, under certain conditions financial instruments may not contain state aid. This is when public authorities act as ‘private investors’. This means that state aid cannot be presumed to exist in all financial instruments. It must first be established through market analysis.

Second, when state aid is found to be present it is not always possible to quantify it. For this reason the state aid rules that apply to financial instruments differ significantly from other rules.

This paper reviews how financial instruments have been assessed by the European Commission and under which conditions the state aid they may contain can be considered to be compatible with the internal market. The paper finds that by and large Member States have succeeded to design measures that have all been approved by the Commission.

College of Europe: Study: European Economic Studies: Research Activities: Bruges European Economic Policy briefings (BEEP) https://www.coleurope.eu/website/study/european-economic-studies/research-activities/bruges-european-economic-policy

---